
Recently, Gallup reported that the number one value of concern to Democrats (from a list of 12, see below) was equality. Among Republicans, equality ranked 11th. Meanwhile, patriotism was number one for Republicans and dead last among Democrats. How can this be a good thing for the country to have this division? We are at a real point of inflection.
Below are the actual rankings.
| OVERALL | DEMOCRATS | REPUBLICANS |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Honesty | Equality | Patriotism |
| 2. Responsibility | Fairness | Responsibility |
| 3. Integrity | Honesty | Honesty |
| 4. Equality | Integrity | Integrity |
| 5. Fairness | Kindness | Respect |
| 6. Freedom | Responsibility | Freedom |
| 7. Respect | Courage (tie) | Courage |
| 8. Courage (tie) | Freedom (tie) | Fairness |
| 9. Patriotism (tie) | Respect | Kindness (tie) |
| 10. Kindness | Service | Humility (tie) |
| 11. Humility | Humility | Equality |
| 12. Service | Patriotism | Service |
Two Competing Visions for America
For the brave few who follow my musings, you are aware of my strongly held view that we are in the midst of living in a country where we no longer have a shared, consensus vision of where we want to go, and the arguments are over how best to get there. Instead, it is now a battle between two competing, very different visions for what is best for our country. Substantially, my argument is that the above table certainly does nothing to undermine my basic thought of two Americas, existing side-by-side. However, this division is not my focus today. Instead, the discussion centers on why it is not a good idea to make equality the number one value.
When Equality Becomes a Demand for Equal Outcomes
My faith includes a strong belief and trust that all of us are equal in the eyes of God. That is quite different than a worldview based on circular logic that is destined to bring about nothing except some shared form of mediocrity. That circular logic is defined by first arguing that, since we are all equal, any outcome that disproportionately favors one group of people over another (especially involving categories such as race, nationality, gender, sexual orientation, etc.) is, by definition, a demonstration of the “system” itself being flawed and requiring change (almost always involving the government) to achieve more equal outcomes. After all, only equal outcomes are acceptable.
It will always be more difficult to elevate the standards and performance of those at the lower end than to simply lower the standards to create outcomes acceptable to those for whom equality is priority one. Whether it is eliminating gifted and talented classes at public schools, or changing the criteria for admission, or 20 other things, this lowering of standards is precisely what has been happening far too often for far too long to suit me.
Why Excellence Should Be the Priority
My preference is that we replace equality with excellence as the top priority to accomplish. Life should not be a zero-sum game. When you do well, there is nothing that means this intrinsically comes at my expense or anyone else’s. Where is the moral virtue in arguing that only outcomes where all of us are tightly grouped are to be desired? Why would not the “best you” sometimes be a lot better than my “best me”?
On the one hand, we are supposed to spend much time celebrating the differences among ourselves. On the other hand, if those differences mean one of us accomplishes a lot more than the other, why is it not the proper reaction for whoever is in second place to try harder, practice more, and establish doing better as the goal versus complaining about things? If that goal is not achieved, my argument is that the proper response is more often than not to chalk it up to the reality that there will be lots of times hard work and good intentions do not produce the results we desire. Still, keeping hard work and good intentions as virtues seems to be justified. What is not justified is to argue that one of us “deserves” better just because not winning makes somebody feel bad.
Fair Opportunity Does Not Guarantee Equal Results
We can discuss just what the standards should be to meet the condition of the competition being fair. We can discuss assuring, as a society, we do all that we can to make the opportunity to compete in life fair. We can discuss what is fair to do concerning those who find themselves at the lower end of the economic spectrum—fair both as it pertains to assuring the competition is as fair as possible and fair when it comes to minimizing suffering. However, no amount of virtue signaling will negate the reality that there are a substantial number of people who feel themselves entitled to a given standard of living and who behave accordingly.
The Case for a Culture of Excellence
As a society, we simply cannot sustain a standard of living that requires constant innovation and improvement unless we commit to excellence being the value that allows for other values to get the attention we want them to receive. The economic house of cards depends on an America with a well-educated workforce within a culture that prizes hard work and competition. We do ourselves no favors by making the priority assuring that nobody feels bad about their plight in life. Do better, or learn to live happily with where you find yourself. Demand a fair chance, not a specific outcome. In some places, this is called life.
America’s Future Depends on Excellence
Committing to and appreciating excellence as the gold standard is step one to our having a real future as a country and society. Next week, we tackle what a crumbling public education system means to even wanting to do the right thing, much less doing the hard work it takes to achieve it. Against a standard of sanity, they are making a challenging situation worse by the day. For now, we will close with a reminder that nowhere is it written that the liberty, freedom, and opportunity we enjoy as Americans are guaranteed to future generations. Excellence is what is needed now, more than ever.https://thinkamerican.news/opinions/faith-politics-worship-god-not-partisan-agendas/
RECENT










BE THE FIRST TO KNOW

More Content By
Bill Greener











