Teddy Sharkey on Sacrifice, Crossroads, and Betting on the Hard Path

In this episode, hosts Jessica Curtis and Rob Semerano sit down with professional pitcher Teddy Sharkey to unpack one of the most pivotal moments in any athlete’s career: the decision to walk away from one passion to go “all-in” on another. For Teddy, that meant the bittersweet choice to leave the football field behind to fully commit his future to the pitcher’s mound.

The Weight of the Crossroad

Teddy Sharkey reflects on the internal tug-of-war that comes with being a multi-sport standout. Choosing a single path isn’t just about logistics; it’s a sacrifice of identity. He shares the vulnerability required to step away from the immediate gratification of football for the long-term, grueling grind of professional baseball. This conversation highlights that the “less comfortable path” is often the one that leads to the highest peak, provided you have the stomach for the journey.

A Foundation of Trust

No athlete reaches the professional level in a vacuum. Teddy Sharkey emphasizes the critical role of his inner circle, discussing how trust in family and mentors provided the emotional safety net he needed to take such a significant risk. When the “noise” of outside expectations gets loud, Teddy explains how friendships helped him stay grounded in his personal vision.

The Cost of “All-In”

What does it actually mean to commit? According to Teddy, it’s a trifecta of discipline:

• Physically: Pushing the body past previous limits.
• Mentally: Silencing the “what-ifs” of the abandoned path.
• Emotionally: Maintaining belief when the results aren’t immediate.

This episode is a masterclass in patience and perspective. Whether you’re an athlete at a crossroad or a professional facing a career pivot, Teddy’s story serves as a powerful reminder that success isn’t just about talent—it’s about the courage to choose your own path.

The Progress Report is where optimism meets action. Hosted by Jessica Curtis and Rob Semerano, this weekly podcast shines a light on the people, ideas, and innovations moving America forward. From unsung heroes to household names, each episode dives into personal stories of resilience, leadership, creativity, and grit. It’s not about politics—it’s about progress. Whether it’s a high school wrestler overcoming the odds, a local business changing lives, or a national figure sharing lessons from the frontlines, The Progress Report celebrates the spirit that keeps this country going. Tune in, get inspired, and be reminded: the American story is still being written